Export Control Review

Version 28 (Aaron Harper, 06/18/2015 05:36 pm)

1 1 J. Simmons
h1. Export Control Review
2 1 J. Simmons
3 1 J. Simmons
This review uses Mach 30's draft "Export Control Review Process":https://docs.google.com/document/d/1GnT5CLXZBoSRHVLcsWU3-tOUXXcInvZHPFFrOJri3GY/pub. The "Export Control Task Force":http://mach30.org/activites/oshw-community-support/ectf/ (ECTF) is responsible for the shape of and guidance through the review process.  The project team is responsible for using the review process.
4 1 J. Simmons
5 20 Aaron Harper
h2. 1. Define the project and related topics in writing for future reference
6 1 J. Simmons
7 1 J. Simmons
# Goals
8 1 J. Simmons
## What is the vision of the project?
9 9 Aaron Harper
The Yavin Thruster will be used at at universities across the country to bring hands on experiences into their propulsion courses and by Mach 30 to demonstrate rocket propulsion as part of its educational and outreach goals.
10 1 J. Simmons
## What ultimate purpose does it serve?
11 5 J. Simmons
To facilitate the education of Mach 30 volunteers,undergraduate aerospace and high level high school students in Newton's laws of motion and rocket propulsion (f = ma, fundamental performance characteristics, fundamental design parameters) in a laboratory setting with instructor involvement. Unit will be able to be built with commonly available components and 3D printed parts.
12 1 J. Simmons
## How does it fit into Mach 30’s strategy?
13 9 Aaron Harper
Continued evolution of Mach30's R&D capabilities in rocket propulsion introducing propulsion system design in addition to the testing capabilities provided by the Shepard Test Stand.
14 1 J. Simmons
## To what use will the results of the project be put?
15 9 Aaron Harper
It will be the one half of a rocket propulsion educational kit, expanding Mach30's portfolio of open source spaceflight hardware projects. 
16 1 J. Simmons
# Technologies
17 1 J. Simmons
## What is the core technology the project will work on?
18 10 Aaron Harper
Undergraduate level rocket propulsion, structural mechanics, pneumatic controls, basic embedded systems instrumentation and control.
19 1 J. Simmons
## What other technologies are necessary to accomplish that work?
20 10 Aaron Harper
3D printing, parametric CAD
21 1 J. Simmons
## What words would an expert use to describe these technologies?
22 11 Aaron Harper
### Rocket Propulsion
23 13 Aaron Harper
### Additive manufacturing
24 12 Aaron Harper
### Pneumatic controls
25 12 Aaron Harper
### Embedded systems
26 12 Aaron Harper
### Instrumentation and control
27 12 Aaron Harper
### Parametric CAD
28 1 J. Simmons
### Cold gas thruster
29 1 J. Simmons
## What words would an average person use to describe these technologies?
30 13 Aaron Harper
### Rockets
31 13 Aaron Harper
### 3D Printing
32 13 Aaron Harper
### Pneumatics
33 13 Aaron Harper
### Arduino
34 13 Aaron Harper
### Sensors, valves, and actuators
35 13 Aaron Harper
### CAD
36 1 J. Simmons
# Inputs and Outputs
37 1 J. Simmons
## What are the project’s major milestones?
38 17 Aaron Harper
### Formal EC review
39 17 Aaron Harper
### Structural analysis of pressure vessel as a Python library. The library should be tested in MTK, producing a document verifying the library. The design should then be implemented in CADQuery.
40 17 Aaron Harper
### Model threaded connection for nozzle to cold gas source in CADQuery
41 17 Aaron Harper
### 3D Printed PLA properties test to verify that the material will hold up under pressure.
42 17 Aaron Harper
### Develop Yavin required calibration process for 3D printers to ensure optimal print quality in PLA. The process will be tested by verifying that it works successfully on another printer.
43 17 Aaron Harper
### Define the bell nozzle contour as a Python library. The library should be tested in MTK, producing a document verifying the library. The design should then be implemented in CADQuery.
44 17 Aaron Harper
### Replicate cold gas thruster design case from Space Propulsion Analysis and Design (SPAD) as a Python library. The library should be tested in MTK, producing a document verifying the library. The design should then be implemented in CADQuery (use an assumed thickness and a conical nozzle).
45 17 Aaron Harper
### Run a Mach 30 volunteer's 3D printer through at least 1 published calibration test and document results in a short report
46 1 J. Simmons
## What previous projects does this one build off of?
47 14 Aaron Harper
Shepard Test Stand
48 1 J. Simmons
## What future projects will build off of this one?
49 16 Aaron Harper
Next generation educational rocket test stand. It will be the one half of a rocket propulsion educational kit referenced in question 1.4 above.
50 1 J. Simmons
## Does this project make use of any specialized, pre-existing knowledge?
51 24 Aaron Harper
Undergraduate and graduate level rocket propulsion technologies as published in commonly available textbooks such as:
52 27 Aaron Harper
### Sellers, Jerry Jon, and William J. Astore. _Understanding Space: An Introduction to Astronautics._ 3rd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Companies, 2005.
53 27 Aaron Harper
### Henry, Gary N. _Space Propulsion Analysis and Design._ "SPAD" New York: McGraw-Hill, 1995.
54 27 Aaron Harper
### Thomson, William Tyrrell. _Introduction to Space Dynamics._ New York: Dover, 1986.
55 28 Aaron Harper
### Ruiter, Anton H. J., and Christopher Damaren. _Spacecraft Dynamics and Control: An Introduction._ New York: Wiley, 2013.
56 28 Aaron Harper
### Wertz, James Richard. _Spacecraft Attitude Determination and Control._ Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1994.
57 1 J. Simmons
## Does this project have any measurable or tangible outcomes?
58 16 Aaron Harper
Enables the development of the rocket propulsion education kit referenced in 1.4 above. 
59 1 J. Simmons
# Keywords
60 1 J. Simmons
## What keywords/phrases summarize the previous answers?
61 18 Aaron Harper
### Rocket
62 18 Aaron Harper
### Propulsion
63 18 Aaron Harper
### Cold gas 
64 18 Aaron Harper
### Nozzle
65 18 Aaron Harper
### Thruster
66 18 Aaron Harper
### Reaction
67 18 Aaron Harper
### Thrust
68 18 Aaron Harper
### RCS
69 18 Aaron Harper
### CGT
70 1 J. Simmons
## What additional keywords/phrases are relevant?
71 18 Aaron Harper
### CAD
72 18 Aaron Harper
### Parametric
73 18 Aaron Harper
### Valve
74 1 J. Simmons
## Put those keywords into a thesaurus; what other relevant keywords appear?
75 18 Aaron Harper
### Booster
76 18 Aaron Harper
### Impulse
77 1 J. Simmons
78 1 J. Simmons
h2. 2. Research the project’s relationship to relevant EC
79 1 J. Simmons
80 1 J. Simmons
# USML
81 1 J. Simmons
## Follow the DDTC’s "Order of Review Decision":http://pmddtc.state.gov/licensing/dt_OrderofReview.htm tool
82 21 Aaron Harper
*No hits*
83 1 J. Simmons
## Run all keywords identified in the previous steps through the text of the "USML":https://www.pmddtc.state.gov/regulations_laws/documents/official_itar/ITAR_Part_121.pdf
84 1 J. Simmons
## Run all keywords, along with words like “ITAR”, “USML” and “export control” through Google
85 1 J. Simmons
# CCL
86 1 J. Simmons
## Run all keywords identified in the previous step through the text of the CCL
87 1 J. Simmons
## Run all keywords, along with words like “EAR”, “CCL” and “export control” through Google
88 1 J. Simmons
# MTCR
89 1 J. Simmons
## Run all keywords identified in the previous step through the text of the MTCR
90 1 J. Simmons
## Run all keywords, along with words like “MTCR” and “export control” through Google
91 23 J. Simmons
92 22 Aaron Harper
*All searches outlined above are documented in the "linked spreadsheet":https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1iFwZptc3YqgfzRV9eH6YTZB_QCIHb8fgPCLb9BT8HCc/edit?usp=sharing*
93 1 J. Simmons
94 19 Aaron Harper
h2. 3. Document findings
95 1 J. Simmons
96 1 J. Simmons
# Summarize the topic(s) that are explicitly mentioned in EC regulations and/or professional analysis/discussion of EC regulations
97 21 Aaron Harper
*The use of a cold gas thruster not designed for use is a specific vehicle in testing and education is not explicitly mentioned and/or is exempt from all known export control regulations; distribution unlimited.*
98 1 J. Simmons
# Explain any additional concerns
99 21 Aaron Harper
*None*
100 1 J. Simmons
# List searches and terms that turned up no relevant results
101 21 Aaron Harper
## Cold gas
102 21 Aaron Harper
## Nozzle
103 21 Aaron Harper
## Reaction
104 21 Aaron Harper
## Thrust
105 21 Aaron Harper
## Valve
106 21 Aaron Harper
## RCS
107 21 Aaron Harper
## CGT
108 21 Aaron Harper
## CAD
109 21 Aaron Harper
## Rocket
110 21 Aaron Harper
## Propulsion
111 21 Aaron Harper
## Parametric
112 1 J. Simmons
113 19 Aaron Harper
h2. 4. Triggers
114 1 J. Simmons
115 1 J. Simmons
# If possible, define any measurable limits the project cannot cross and an appropriate margin for error
116 21 Aaron Harper
*Once Yavin designs and/or technologies are used in a launch vehicle or spacecraft, it becomes export controlled under both ITAR and the EAR.*
117 1 J. Simmons
# Specify, or guess at, any future dates when relevant information is expected to be become available
118 21 Aaron Harper
*N/A*
119 1 J. Simmons
# Maintain a clear distinction between information used as-is and any changes, additions, derivations, etc added by Mach 30
120 21 Aaron Harper
*Provided the CGT technologies are not used on aircraft, launch vehicles, or spacecraft, no restrictions are known to exist.*
121 1 J. Simmons
122 19 Aaron Harper
h2. 5. Reevaluate if a trigger is flipped. 
123 2 J. Simmons
124 2 J. Simmons
Repeat this process if there are any major changes to the project. Update this report at each major milestone.